Back When Everyone Read His Grammar Book

Where are you in the grammar debate/squabble over singular third person pronouns? When anybody is opening a door, should we write that anybody is opening his door, his or her door, or their door? I’ll state upfront that using his or her is just a waste of words and speedbump in your sentence. The issue is really whether we should use the singular his or the plural their, becoming comfortable with their being used for one person.

Until today, I thought his was the singular, gender neutral pronoun, and unless you’re talking about girls (like I am when I talk about the little people in my home), then you should say things like everyone should use his napkin, not his shirt. This afternoon, I read in an NYT article that they has been used for individuals for centuries, and a grammarian named Anne Fisher changed it.

Fisher’s popular guide, “A New Grammar” (1745), ran to more than 30 editions, making it one of the most successful grammars of its time. More important, it’s believed to be the first to say that the pronoun he should apply to both sexes. . . . Meanwhile, many great writers — Byron, Austen, Thackeray, Eliot, Dickens, Trollope and more — continued to use they and company as singulars, never mind the grammarians.

Well, if Austen, Thackeray, Eliot, et al used it, I’m not going to complain ever again.

0 thoughts on “Back When Everyone Read His Grammar Book”

  1. I’ve always used “he” for “everyone” or “anyone.” (“He or she” is way too cumbersome and “they” just sounds wrong to me.) Is Roy Jacobsen around? I’d be interested in his opinion.

  2. I don’t have my library at hand, but I have read a couple of authorities that say “they” has an august history of use as a singular pronoun, and “their” as the singular possessive. I can try to find some citations if y’all would like.

    Personally, I think “they/their” used for a single antecedent person of unknown gender is perfectly fine. (But then I’ve been known to split infinitives and end sentences with prepositions in public. And I begin sentences with “hopefully” before Labor Day. After Labor Day, as well.)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.