Historian Thomas Kidd is writing about Josiah Franklin, candlemaker and Benjamin Frankin’s Calvinist father.
In the late 1670s a wave of intense persecution came against nonconformists across England, as many church and government officials regarded them as dangerous incendiaries who might once again threaten the stability of the nation. . . . University of Oxford officials sanctioned the public burning of writings by non-Anglican luminaries such as John Milton. Even pacifist Quakers, who would soon found Franklin’s longtime home of Pennsylvania, were jailed under brutal conditions and died by the hundreds during the 1680s. Northamptonshire was a hotbed of nonconformity, and in one episode in the mid-1680s more than fifty members of landowning gentry were arrested on suspicion of seditious religious activity.
According to what I’ve read, Franklin was hostile to Calvinism most of his life, but mellowed in his old age. He resolved in a letter, when his grandson came to live with him, to raise the boy as a Presbyterian.
Perhaps his father left a bad taste in his mouth or not enough of a good taste to counter the influence of the other non-conformists around them. Pennsylvania wasn’t full of Calvinists, I don’t think.