Tonight’s dyspeptic screed concerns the essential dishonesty of movies.
Which I mean in the most positive sense.
I’m not going to go off on a classic Christian Fundamentalist jeremiad against Hollywood as the Whore of Babylon, the cancer that is slowing destroying our culture.
(Although, when I read those old denunciations, I’m struck by two things: 1) they were in general factually correct, and 2) all the bad effects the critics predicted that movies would bring about have in fact come to pass. You can’t fault them as prophets.)
But my subject is the dishonesty that is inherent (it seems to me) in the medium.
Christians of a legalistic bent often complain that fiction is, by definition, “just lying stories.”
Without getting into that argument, I think I’m justified in saying that novels are scrupulously truthful when compared to movies. Continue reading Cinema: the devil’s zoetrope