The temperature was up around forty today. In Minnesota, in February, that counts as a beautiful day. The sun shone, and our thin snow cover faded like the new congressโs gravitas.
I even had time for a walk before sundown, though evening shadows were lengthening by the time I finished. As an added bonus, somebody had left a bookcase out in front of their house, with a โFreeโ sign taped to it. I jumped into Mrs. Hermanson, drove back and snagged it. Itโs kind of beat up, granted, but I meant it for the basement. I can never have enough bookcases.
S. T. Karnick has been relentlessly asking hard questions about the Tim Hardaway controversy. Iโm not sure I agree entirely with his position, but Iโm not sure I entirely agree with my own either. Assuming I have one.
When I was young I came to embrace a passionate, Jeffersonian view of freedom of speech. I believed the American approach was essentially based in a Christian world view. If everybody, regardless of how outrageous his opinion, is permitted to make his case the best he can, the marketplace of ideas will make the truth evident to all, because thereโs power in Truth.
However, thereโs another way to look at it, also based in a Christian world view. That approach would say that, since human beings are sinful and essentially perverse, they will always choose the answers they find most convenient, flattering and profitable, regardless of the merits of the arguments.
When arguing with people about vulgar music and movies, whenever Iโve been subjected to the inevitable accusation that I’m in favor of censorship, my standard response has been to say, โNo, I donโt want censorship. I want public opinion to shame these people into silence. I want to make publishers ashamed to produce this stuff.โ
Which is precisely what the left is doing with Hardaway.
So I ought to be OK with that.
But I canโt dismiss Karnickโs argument that itโs pretty hypocritical for people to self-righteously pretend they donโt share Hardawayโs feelings to some extent, and to justify themselves by throwing stones at him.
Iโll let you know if I come to any conclusions.