Beauty was once the goal, at least in part, of art, music, and poetry. Now, it is the antithesis of them, states Roger Scruton, who has written a book on the subject.
Of course, there were great artists who tried to rescue beauty from the perceived disruption of modern society—as T. S. Eliot tried to recompose, in Four Quartets, the fragments he had grieved over in The Waste Land. And there were others, particularly in America, who refused to see the sordid and the transgressive as the truth of the modern world. For artists like Hopper, Samuel Barber, and Wallace Stevens, ostentatious transgression was mere sentimentality, a cheap way to stimulate an audience, and a betrayal of the sacred task of art, which is to magnify life as it is and to reveal its beauty—as Stevens reveals the beauty of “An Ordinary Evening in New Haven” and Barber that of Knoxville: Summer of 1915. But somehow those great life-affirmers lost their position at the forefront of modern culture. So far as the critics and the wider culture were concerned, the pursuit of beauty was at the margins of the artistic enterprise. Qualities like disruptiveness and immorality, which previously signified aesthetic failure, became marks of success; while the pursuit of beauty became a retreat from the real task of artistic creation. This process has been so normalized as to become a critical orthodoxy, prompting the philosopher Arthur Danto to argue recently that beauty is both deceptive as a goal and in some way antipathetic to the mission of modern art. Art has acquired another status and another social role.
Thanks, Phil.
So true. So sad.
I’m all anti-hero’d out.
I’m reminded of a story I heard or read somewhere. It was about an English critic who was taking a walking tour. In the Scottish highlands or someplace. As his party reached the top of a hill, they were greeted by the sight of a glorious sunset. “Oh, how beautiful!” said someone.
“Derivative,” said the critic.
I would like for art (meaning most everything creative) to be concerned as much with skill as beauty. Covering a urinal with gold leaf doesn’t count as art in my book. That being said, I don’t mind shocking works as long as they’re done with an eye towards excellence. The Isenheim Altarpiece always comes to mind during these discussions. While it may not be exactly beautiful, it is excellently crafted.
Post Script: Got a good chuckle out of your ocmment, Lars.