We Have Seen the Culture, And It Is Us

Jonathan D. Fitzgerald has an article criticizing Pastor Mark Discoll called “Disengage Culture.” He makes a good point about what culture is and how it’s odd for Christians to talk about engaging it, as if it were something outside of us. An interesting discussion has come up in the comments.

The Edge, by Dick Francis

The Edge

A few days back I mentioned a book I was reading that was so languid that I had trouble staying with it. The Edge, I shall now reveal, is that book.

Train stories are an interesting genre. In books and movies, a railroad train can provide the stage for high drama—derailments, dynamiting, bridge collapses, mysterious strangers all packed into a limited space, engines racing against the clock.

In real life, most rail journeys are pretty dull. Aside from enjoying the scenery—which depends heavily on where you’re traveling—the passenger has to pretty much bring, or make, his own entertainment. It’s nice not to have to drive, but driving at least gives you something to occupy your mind.

Sadly, The Edge is more like a real train journey than a movie one. Great stretches of prose pass by the coach window, all of it moving the story forward, but at a glacial pace. The climax, like the distant Rockies, looms forever (it seems) in the distance. Points of interest are far between.

The hero is Tor Kelsey, a special agent for the British Jockey Club. Independently wealthy, he could afford to live a life of leisure, but he was raised to do useful things and keep busy. In his professional capacity he’s developed a facility for being overlooked, for fading into crowds in order to observe unobserved.

As the book opens, he’s trailing a suspect, a man who probably murdered a jockey on the orders of a shady horse owner named Filmer, who recently got off on a charge of blackmail. The strong arm man, unfortunately, drops dead of a heart attack, leaving Kelsey without a good line on Filmer.

Then word comes that Filmer plans to join a much-publicized race event in Canada. Called the Great Transcontinental Mystery Race Train, the exclusive excursion will send major race horse owners from Montreal to Vancouver, in a special luxury train featuring, for their added pleasure, a scripted mystery play. It appears that one or two of the travelers are about to be further victims of Filmer’s schemes, so Kelsey is delegated to join the crew as a waiter and actor, while keeping an eye on Filmer.

Which he does. Unfortunately, Filmer does almost nothing except ingratiate himself with the other owners for most of the book, which dampens the excitement. There’s finally some real action when they get to the Rockies, but even that seems to me underdeveloped, considering the possibilities. Many characters (I had a hard time keeping track of them) interact, mostly without a lot of drama.

Francis is a genial author, and Tor Kelsey an appealing character. But I found myself wondering, for many, many pages, why I should care what happened next.

Eaton proves himself worthy

Loren Eaton, at I Saw Lightning Fall, likes Andrew Klavan’s Damnation Street, and considers it a satisfying finale to the Weiss/Bishop detective trilogy.

I am pleased. Well done.

He didn't lay His glory by quite this much…

Christmas geese

A friend on Facebook linked to this remarkable collection of some of the most tasteless Nativity Scenes that ever unaccountably failed to bring down the wrath of angels.

Except for the Dog Nativity, of course. The Dog Nativity is awesome.

Links of interest. To me, anyway

Arbol Navidad

Photo credit: Jorge Barrios.

The picture above is intended to induce holiday cheer, and possibly petit-mal seizures. Also because I haven’t gotten my own tree up yet.

Under the tree, a few links, just for you.

At First Things, Joe Carter points us to an interesting article from First Principles, on the true worth of the Puritans and Puritanism.

At City Journal, Andrew Klavan has a short story. Not Christmasy.

Mike Gray at The American Culture links to a Telegraph report on a debate on religion, between Tony Blair and Christopher Hitchens.

And Standpoint has an excellent (what else?) review of a new book about Chesterton, with an appreciation, by the inestimable Paul Johnson. I forget who pointed me to it.

Figment Invites Teens to Write More

Figment.com is a new site for teenagers who want to find new writing and write it themselves. The NY Times has a write-up on it. Want to write some great work for the cellular age? This may be your starting point. Just don’t get cocky.

What is Sin?

In a letter to John Wesley in June 1735, his mother Susanna Wesley wrote these words:

The beauty, pleasures, and ease of the body strangely charm us; the wealth and honours of the world allure us; and all, under the management of a subtle malicious adversary, give a prodigious force to present things; and if the animal life once get the ascendant of our reason, it is the greatest folly imaginable, because he seeks it where has not designed he shall ever find it. But this is the case of the generality of men; they live as mere animals, wholly given up to the interests and pleasures of the body; and all the use of their understanding is to make provision for the flesh to fulfil the lusts thereof, without the least regard to future happiness or misery.

I take à Kempis to have been an honest weak man, with more zeal than knowledge, by his condemning all mirth or pleasure as sinful or useless, in opposition to so many plain and direct texts of Scripture. Would you judge of the lawfulness or unlawfulness of pleasure; of the innocence or malignity of actions? Take this rule: whatever weakens your reason, impairs the tenderness of your conscience, obscures your sense of God, or takes off the relish of spiritual things; in short, whatever increases the strength and authority of your body over your mind, that thing is sin to you, however innocent it may be in itself.

(from Susanna Wesley by Eliza Clarke LONDON: W. H. ALLEN & CO., 1886)

Weather note, plus dialectic

If it has to happen, I guess this is the night for it. As much as eight inches of snow is expected tonight. There’s no pressure to fire up the snowblower before morning, when delivery is complete. So I can relax tonight, and I have my work planned for me tomorrow.

So far it’s been a pretty textbook winter here. Cold and snow have arrived right on schedule. I was going to make a joke about Global Warming promoters saying, “It’s quiet. Too quiet.” But they’re having crazy weather in Europe, so that doesn’t work.

But has there ever been a year when the weather wasn’t crazy someplace in the world?

Below, my simple, three-step template for social change in the modern world. Our cast of characters consist of a Liberal and a Conservative.



Step One:


Liberal: Let’s do this! It’ll be great!

Conservative: I don’t know. Seems like that might change everything.

Liberal: Nah, don’t worry about it. Nothing important will change. You won’t notice a thing.

Step Two:

Conservative: Everything has changed. You said it wouldn’t.

Liberal: Why are you afraid of change?

Step Three:

Conservative: Everything has changed, and it’s all gotten worse.

Liberal: You’re a bigot.