Category Archives: Reviews

Night of Thunder, by Stephen Hunter

Night of Thunder

I’d fallen behind in my Stephen Hunter reading the last year or so. I get most of my books from a used book store, and they never seem to have any Hunter in stock. But I recently got a chance to order his two most recent paperbacks, and Night of Thunder is the first in line.

Night of Thunder is about NASCAR, the races, the business, and the culture. It exhibits many of the qualities of NASCAR itself—lots of action, lots of color, plenty of thrills, and very little substance. In other words, Night of Thunder is an entertainment, the most purely cotton candy, Coors-in-a-cooler, hoo-rah spectacle of any of Hunter’s novels. That sounds like a put-down, but it all depends on what you’re looking for. Nobody delivers more entertainment per consumer dollar than Stephen Hunter, and you’ll have fun with this book. But I don’t think you’ll remember it long. Continue reading Night of Thunder, by Stephen Hunter

James Church's Inspector O novels: An appreciation

A Corpse in the Koryo Hidden Moon Bamboo and Blood The Man With the Baltic Stare
I have now finished reading all four of “James Church”’s Inspector O novels. (“O,” by the way, is not an initial. It’s the man’s family name.) I can’t claim to understand them fully, but I unquestionably enjoyed them. They are tragic stories, but they didn’t depress me.
Quite remarkable books, all in all. I won’t forget them.
I’ve reviewed the first book, A Corpse in the Koryo, already.
The second book, Hidden Moon, involves a bank robbery—the first, we are informed, in North Korean history.
The third book, Bamboo and Blood, surprises us by jumping back in time. It’s set in the winter of 1997, during the great North Korean famine. It involves an Israeli spy and the murder of diplomat’s wife, and takes O to Switzerland and New York City, where (oddly) he shows no particular interest in food, though he thought about it a lot in A Corpse in the Koryo.
The final book, The Man with the Baltic Stare (I assume it’s the last, though I don’t actually know—it just has the feel of tying off loose ends), is the most audacious of the lot. It’s set in the future, around 2014, and involves the (supposed) murder of a prostitute by a young Korean diplomat in Prague. O, who has, we are informed, been banished (rather to his relief) to the countryside, to live on a mountain top and make wooden toys, is commanded to travel to Prague (there are references to Kafka) to investigate. Continue reading James Church's Inspector O novels: An appreciation

DVD Review: Arn: The Knight Templar

Arn: The Knight Templar
Who’d have imagined that the best knights and armor movie since Braveheart (discounting The Lord of the Rings trilogy, a fantasy) would come out of Sweden, of all places?
Arn: The Knight Templar (available on DVD and Blue Ray) is an adaptation (much truncated, I understand) of a Swedish television miniseries based on a trilogy of novels by Jan Guillou. The hero is Arn Magnusson (Joakim Nätterkvist), a young man who was raised in a monastery, but trained in arms by a monk who was once a Knight Templar. Returning to his family, he falls in love with a neighbor’s daughter, Cecilia (Sofia Helin). Unfortunately her father’s political obligations make their match impossible. But the two young people manage to get together long enough to conceive a child. The ensuing scandal results in her being confined to a nunnery, and him being sent to join the Knights Templar on crusade in the Holy Land.
The storytelling requirements of fitting all this into the 133 minute run time make for a lot of intercutting and flashbacks (you do have to pay attention), but we follow their separate trials and and struggles for the next twenty years. The focus is on Arn, who becomes a legendary fighter in the Holy Land, one whom the Muslim armies recognize, fear, and respect. He even becomes a friend of Saladin, a circumstance which saves his life (what would fictional crusaders ever do without Saladin to pull their escutcheons out of the fire?). After their time of punishment is complete, Arn and Cecilia are reunited and married, but one final challenge remains for his warrior skills. Continue reading DVD Review: Arn: The Knight Templar

Film review: "The Voyage of the Dawn Treader"

(If you’ve seen the following review already posted at The American Culture, you may be wondering why I posted it first there, which is not my usual practice. The reason is that I was asked specifically by Sam Karnick of TAC to write this review last weekend, but was prevented by the weather from getting to the theater. So after I’d viewed the film yesterday, I made haste to post it for TAC as quickly as possible.)



The big question you’re bringing to this review, I’m pretty sure, is, “Is The Voyage of the Dawn Treader worthy of its source? Is it more like the first movie, which we loved, or the second movie, which we didn’t even bother to see?”

I’m happy to report that for one C. S. Lewis geek at least, the movie was very satisfying and provided an extremely good time at the movies. (I saw it in 3D. I don’t know if that matters or not; you’re on your own on whether to spend the money. Personally, I’m a sucker for flashy magic.)

It should always be borne in mind that books and movies are different species of story. What works for one may not work for the other (though it’s nice when they do). I ask just three things of a film adaptation of a beloved novel. First, it should make some effort to follow the general outline of the original (extra points for dialogue faithfully carried over). Second, it should hit most of the dramatic high points. And third, it should deliver something like the same emotional impact.

For this particular viewer, The Voyage of the Dawn Treader succeeded. Very well. I’m not sure yet, but I might even like it better than the first movie. Continue reading Film review: "The Voyage of the Dawn Treader"

A Corpse In the Koryo, by James Church

A Corpse In the Koryo

I’d never heard of author James Church (a pseudonym for a former western intelligence officer) before someone lent me A Corpse in the Koryo. It’s carefully written, in a restrained, picturesque style that seems (to me, as an ignorant westerner) evocative of Asian thinking. And it delivers all the grim tragedy one expects, in a story set in North Korea.

Inspector O, a police detective in Pyongyang, is a loose cannon in the honored tradition of fictional cops. Of course, a loose cannon in North Korea enjoys a lot less scope than one in, say, Los Angeles. He expresses his individuality through small acts of rebellion, like “forgetting” to wear the uniform badge that bears the portrait of the Dear Leader, and pursuing the solitary (hence suspect) hobby of woodworking, when he can get his hands on wood and supplies.

He’s lucky, too. He’s the grandson of a national hero, and a government minister who was his grandfather’s friend gives him a certain level of protection.

Still, Inspector O is under constant suspicion. But then, everyone is under constant suspicion.

The story, presented as a debriefing given to a British agent, begins with Inspector O sitting on a hill overlooking a highway, with a camera, waiting for a particular car to pass by. He’s supposed to take a picture of the car, but when he tries, the battery in his camera is dead (par for the course). Shortly after returning to his office, he is told that a little boy has been killed near the site where he had been watching. Then he attends a tense meeting with several police and intelligence officers, and is ordered to go to another city for a while and lay low. However, when he gets there, there are messages and clues, and mysterious meetings.

And so it goes. Nothing is what it seems in O’s world, and anyone not known to be a friend is probably an enemy. No one speaks directly. Messages are conveyed by nuances and things left unsaid. The mystery is convoluted, and the normal difficulties of police work are exacerbated by the difficulty of getting things as simple as aspirin, a meal, or notebooks (to say nothing of information).

But for all the subtleties of Korean society, death is brutal, bloody, and unsparing.

A Corpse In the Koryo is an excellent mystery for grown-ups not afraid of sorrow and futility, and anyone interested in a glimpse into the world’s most closed and secretive society. It’s not an easy read, as the reader needs to pay close attention both to spoken words and silences. Recommended.

Breathless, by Dean Koontz

Breathless

Say what you like about Dean Koontz; he isn’t afraid to experiment and mix it up. Breathless is part spiritual thriller, part science fiction. It’s a book with a clear message, one many readers won’t like. It’s also a very sweet story, and I enjoyed it and was moved by it. For reference, the same spirit that animates the Odd Thomas books is at work here.

Koontz jumps between several characters and story lines, before bringing them together, if not in one place, at least around one theme. A wonderful thing has happened in our world. Each witness to that event responds for the good or the evil, depending on the capacities of their souls.

Because of the multiplicity of story lines, it’s hard to give a synopsis, but the central story involves a man named Grady Adams, who along with his dog Merlin (gratefully, the dog is not a supernatural being this time out) observes the Event while on an evening walk in the woods. Soon he notices strange creatures watching his house. Meanwhile, his friend Camillia Rivers, a veterinarian, is trying to find an explanation for a strange “seizure” experienced by a number of domestic animals, which not only doesn’t seem to have done them any harm, but has done them good.

And nearby a sociopathic murderer is preparing for the collapse of society by building himself a secure compound on a mountain farm.

It all comes together in the end.

If you’re a Koontz fan and a religious believer, you’ll probably enjoy Breathless. If you don’t get the whole religion thing, you may find it offputting.

I don’t recall any very rough language. No sex, and the violence happens early on and is not explicit.

Not Koontz’ best, but recommended, for those with eyes to see.

The Edge, by Dick Francis

The Edge

A few days back I mentioned a book I was reading that was so languid that I had trouble staying with it. The Edge, I shall now reveal, is that book.

Train stories are an interesting genre. In books and movies, a railroad train can provide the stage for high drama—derailments, dynamiting, bridge collapses, mysterious strangers all packed into a limited space, engines racing against the clock.

In real life, most rail journeys are pretty dull. Aside from enjoying the scenery—which depends heavily on where you’re traveling—the passenger has to pretty much bring, or make, his own entertainment. It’s nice not to have to drive, but driving at least gives you something to occupy your mind.

Sadly, The Edge is more like a real train journey than a movie one. Great stretches of prose pass by the coach window, all of it moving the story forward, but at a glacial pace. The climax, like the distant Rockies, looms forever (it seems) in the distance. Points of interest are far between.

The hero is Tor Kelsey, a special agent for the British Jockey Club. Independently wealthy, he could afford to live a life of leisure, but he was raised to do useful things and keep busy. In his professional capacity he’s developed a facility for being overlooked, for fading into crowds in order to observe unobserved.

As the book opens, he’s trailing a suspect, a man who probably murdered a jockey on the orders of a shady horse owner named Filmer, who recently got off on a charge of blackmail. The strong arm man, unfortunately, drops dead of a heart attack, leaving Kelsey without a good line on Filmer.

Then word comes that Filmer plans to join a much-publicized race event in Canada. Called the Great Transcontinental Mystery Race Train, the exclusive excursion will send major race horse owners from Montreal to Vancouver, in a special luxury train featuring, for their added pleasure, a scripted mystery play. It appears that one or two of the travelers are about to be further victims of Filmer’s schemes, so Kelsey is delegated to join the crew as a waiter and actor, while keeping an eye on Filmer.

Which he does. Unfortunately, Filmer does almost nothing except ingratiate himself with the other owners for most of the book, which dampens the excitement. There’s finally some real action when they get to the Rockies, but even that seems to me underdeveloped, considering the possibilities. Many characters (I had a hard time keeping track of them) interact, mostly without a lot of drama.

Francis is a genial author, and Tor Kelsey an appealing character. But I found myself wondering, for many, many pages, why I should care what happened next.

Eaton proves himself worthy

Loren Eaton, at I Saw Lightning Fall, likes Andrew Klavan’s Damnation Street, and considers it a satisfying finale to the Weiss/Bishop detective trilogy.

I am pleased. Well done.

Links of interest. To me, anyway

Arbol Navidad

Photo credit: Jorge Barrios.

The picture above is intended to induce holiday cheer, and possibly petit-mal seizures. Also because I haven’t gotten my own tree up yet.

Under the tree, a few links, just for you.

At First Things, Joe Carter points us to an interesting article from First Principles, on the true worth of the Puritans and Puritanism.

At City Journal, Andrew Klavan has a short story. Not Christmasy.

Mike Gray at The American Culture links to a Telegraph report on a debate on religion, between Tony Blair and Christopher Hitchens.

And Standpoint has an excellent (what else?) review of a new book about Chesterton, with an appreciation, by the inestimable Paul Johnson. I forget who pointed me to it.

The Viking Funeral, by Stephen J. Cannell

I’d been looking for the late Stephen J. Cannell’s The Viking Funeral: A Shane Scully Novel for some time, just because of its title. I’ve enjoyed the other books in the Shane Scully series, and had kept my eye out for it, but the second-hand bookstore where I get most of my books never seemed to have it in.

Having finally found it, I have to confess to a little disappointment. It’s a diverting actioner, and moving in places, but it’s by far the darkest book of the series. I wasn’t prepared for the grimness of the thing.

In this book, our hero Shane Scully spots an old friend driving on the freeway, a friend who—he had every reason to believe—had committed suicide some time before. The friend’s response to catching his eye confirms the identification. His investigation of the matter leads Scully into very deep corruption in the police and sheriff’s departments, and to some terrible moments of betrayal, given and received. Scully spends a good portion of the book grieving his own killing of someone very important in his life.

It’s kind of depressing.

It gets better after a while, but the fun level in this one is pretty low, despite Cannell’s penchant for injecting cinematic violence, explosions, and automatic weapons fire at every opportunity. Worth reading, but not as light as one might hope. Cautions, as usual, for language, violence, and adult subject matter.